On its own, Cole’s elbow injury wouldn’t be a “death sentence.” However, the Yankees are already down designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton (elbows), infielder DJ LeMahieu (calf), starting pitcher Luis Gil (lat), and reliever Scott Effross (hamstring).

A tough setback for the New York Yankees as Gerrit Cole’s injury forces him out, but Aaron Boone made it clear—the team must keep pushing forward despite everything they’re losing without their ace. Aaron Boone understands that losing Gerrit Cole could create unprecedented challenges for the New York Yankees early in the 2025 MLB season.